Capacity Planning vs Resource Planning: What's the Difference for IT Directors?

Introduction: Two Related but Different Concepts

Many IT Directors confuse capacity planning and resource planning. This confusion is understandable because both disciplines are closely related and often used together. However, they are two complementary but distinct approaches, each with its own objectives, methods, and specific tools.

Understanding the difference between these two concepts is essential to implement an effective planning strategy. Confusion can lead to suboptimal decisions, poor resource allocation, or inappropriate investments.

In this comprehensive guide, we'll explore in detail the differences between capacity planning and resource planning, their respective objectives, when to use each, and how to combine them for optimal IT resource management.

What is Resource Planning?

Resource planning focuses on operational allocation of existing resources. It answers the fundamental question: "Who does what and when?"

Resource Planning Characteristics

• Short time horizon: Weeks to a few months maximum
• Operational focus: Concrete allocation of people to projects
• Immediate objective: Meet current needs with available resources
• Fine granularity: Detail at person and day level
• High frequency: Weekly or bi-weekly reviews

What is Capacity Planning?

Capacity planning goes much further. It answers the strategic question: "Do we have enough resources to meet current and future needs?" It integrates strategic analysis, forecasting, and long-term planning.

Capacity Planning Characteristics

• Long time horizon: Quarters to years
• Strategic focus: Analysis of overall capacity and future needs
• Anticipatory objective: Forecast and plan future needs
• Macro granularity: Overview at team/department level
• Moderate frequency: Monthly or quarterly reviews

Key Differences

Resource planning focuses on operations (who does what, when), while capacity planning focuses on strategy (do we have enough, should we recruit).

When to Use Each?

Both approaches are complementary and should be used together for optimal management.

Use Resource Planning for:

• Daily operational planning
• Conflict management
• Operational tracking
• Emergency management

Use Capacity Planning for:

• Strategic planning
• Investment decisions
• Forecasting
• Capacity analysis
• Executive reporting

How to Combine Them Effectively?

For optimal management, combine both approaches: capacity planning to define strategy, and resource planning for operational execution.

Conclusion

Capacity planning and resource planning are two complementary but distinct disciplines. Resource planning focuses on operations (who does what, when), while capacity planning focuses on strategy (do we have enough, should we recruit).

For optimal IT resource management, you must use both approaches together: capacity planning to define strategy, and resource planning for operational execution.

A good tool like Workload integrates both for complete and effective management. Discover how Workload combines resource planning and capacity planning by trying free for 14 days. Setup in 5 minutes, no credit card required.